160
Option to allow failures in Fan-In/Out Workflow
under review
B
Brandon Page
The requires tag in workflows really limits what is possible. Requires makes a lot of sense for the deployment scenario used to demo it, but waiting for a group of jobs to complete (pass or fail) should be an option.
Scenario: Setup -> Run multiple sets of tests in parallel -> Combine test results/coverage results/artifacts and report to PR
That scenario above isn’t possible because if a single test fails in any of the jobs running in parallel the the fan-in step won’t run.
CCI-I-344
Activity
Newest
Oldest
L
Liya Ai
under review
A
Ari Bolton
+1 -- my company has the exact same use case as in the description
Amo Wu
vote
L
Lucian Stoicescu
Use case for my company would be saving screenshots to cloud if the test jobs generates them - this would only be needed if the test job fails (or else there are no screenshots of the failures). We cannot have the upload be part of the test job for various reasons so a require_failed would be perfect
j
jo mo
Use case for me is a smoke test job that runs against master before deploy (should fail and prevent further jobs running , namely build and deploy) but also runs on a nightly schedule in which case it should be able to fail and still have the following job run to notify devs of the failuresteps requiring failure to cease flow - hold-staging: type: approval requires: - smoke-testjob requiring failure to continue flow scheduled-smoke-test: triggers: - schedule: cron: "5 8 *" filters: branches: only: - master jobs: - smoke-test - smoke-test-notification: requires: - smoke-test
K
Kos Huang
This will be huge for us!
g
graham booth
any news on this??
b
bal
Pleaseeeee
R
Rob Duncan
There's been a fair amount of comments on this and no word from CircleCI.
Having worked with thousands of CCI pipelines this has been a huge pain point for us.
A
A
We would like to add tests, that are still under development. getting a notification on their failure is important but they should not be blocking the pipeline yet
Load More
→